There’s something I need to tell you

I’ve been meaning to write this post for a while… It isn’t your usual post full of instructions but I really feel it is worth saying. This issue is not mine alone, as many fellow publishers share in this. I do hope it all works out. Grab a cup… There’s something I need to tell you.

How did I get here!?

Almost 10 years ago I had a ‘hair-brained’ idea to start a blog. It seemed simple enough, I make stuff all the time so why not share it?! After decades of working in the commercial art industry I had developed all the necessary background skills to photograph, edit, write (I hope), illustrate (since I am trained as a technical illustrator) and mostly be able to work in all kinds of media. I did also hold a couple other jobs teaching and freelancing so those pennies that came in with google ads were ok.

I know most who start a website think that it’s an easy way to make lots of money but I was more interested in the sharing aspect. Some sites actually do not create their own material but rather just ‘take’ from what exists, even steal from them. Sure, it needs to be worthwhile since there’s a lot of costs associated with keeping a site alive. I need to have a place where the digital content ‘lives’ and will feed it quickly to you when you want to see & read it. I did learn the software (Wordpress) that allows the design and configuration of the pages pretty easily. Thankfully a graphic designer daughter is my saving grace!

It’s just me…

Did you guess, it is just me, all by myself! I do have some family help sometimes for technical issues but it’s just me making, writing, and posting. Some will tell me to hire a cheap writer but that just seems wrong. How can someone who did not have hands on experience tell you how to do it and gives tips along the way?!

Some of the technical health of a website like speed is also important so I have had to hire web designers to rebuild my site. So many scores & analytics are available to tell you how you are doing. It takes a whole skillset to even know how to read those analytics in depth. ‘But I just want to be creative.

Be unique and different

I am the one who does each project, design it and try to be unique. As an artist I was taught to be unique rather than follow a trend or style. That is great but the internet likes popular subjects and rewards them. That means that if your subject matter or projects is a very niche type it may not rank really high in the eyes of Google. When you search for something, those terms and keywords may have millions of searches so being on the top of the list is crucial. Figuring how to get to the top of the list is another mystery. It is not good enough to just make great content but you need to be a pro at SEO (search engine optimization) Arghhh, I need to use the right words or perhaps hire help.

Where is everyone?!

You can supply the greatest content (tutorials and projects) but if no one comes to visit then it’s not great or sustainable. Traffic numbers translates into the revenue to pay for the costs. Yes, I know you hate those ads between my content but it is a necessary evil.

Well, that sounds reasonably easy? As expected, things are changing all the time. I know it can’t stay the same but as of late it seems much more accelerated! I bet you have already been introduced to AI (Artificial intelligence). It can be a great tool but I worry… As a creative person who was educated in methods that don’t even exist today I have seen so much change, mind-boggling amounts of change. I really do not not want to sound like one of those old bitter people but I see so many effects of these changes, especially in the creative industry. It was very well said; ‘if it comes by too easily it probably isn’t worth it’.

In the ‘olden’ days (yada-yada) we would learn that practice made perfect and take the steps to learn how to get better with perseverance. Well, now you see a project whiz by in seconds and it looks crazy simple. Social media feeds you this and knows what you want to see since there’s a lot of invisible algorithms working behind the scenes. Most never to make it as those surfing hours are now gone.

Answers delivered too quick:

You know how it happens; you search something and there is the answer in short form. Google’s practice of extracting sections from websites and displaying them directly on search results pages (often in the form of featured snippets) has raised significant issues for website owners, content creators, and digital marketers. Even questions and query you haven’t even asked yet are answered.

Since you see an answer you do not travel or click through to the website page. That’s great for you but detrimental for the site owner from where it was pulled from. Imagine getting the pages of a book that you need without buying the book! This scares me as I see traffic sink and wonder what the future holds.

While Google typically provides a link to the source of the snippet, it’s often less visible, and users may overlook it. The content creators are left without being directly credited. This means less brand interaction and user engagement. Another issue is Google’s snippets often provide a limited view, and while convenient, this brief content can sometimes misrepresent or oversimplify the information, since the user only sees a small part of the full context.

Do you really want to see my face?

Oh, and speaking of social media; there is such a push nowadays to post constantly. Do I have time to post every small moment of my day? I can barely keep up with the ‘making’ and creating the content. I’m told I should post my face all the time, but why? I thought you really want to learn how to do things and seeing me doesn’t add much help. Most of the time I probably look dreadful in work clothes anyways!

There’s only so much time in your day and scrolling through Instagram & Facebook for hours leaves little left. Questions are then asked and then there are so many platforms to check and respond to. It makes my head spin and almost makes me keep forgetting what I was doing. I fondly remember the days where only one thing would be happening at a time. I bet it was much more efficient then.

Google Updates and algorithms

I go about making my stuff and then I may look to see that hardly anyone visits. Maybe you have heard about it. Google has made a series of algorithm updates (core update) focused on promoting quality, user-focused content, with the Helpful Content Update (HCU) being one of the most impactful. This update aims to improve your user experience by rewarding genuinely helpful, high-quality content while reducing the visibility of low-quality content that lacks depth, originality, or relevance. In particular, blogs and websites that prioritize search engine optimization (SEO) over user value are facing new challenges. Some of my fellow bloggers have been decimated by these updates and their livelihood has all but disappeared! My traffic graph lines go up & down as I scratch my head.

What is Google’s Helpful Content Update (HCU)?

The Helpful Content Update, launched by Google in 2022, introduced a system that focuses on identifying and devaluing content that is “unhelpful.” This is part of Google’s broader goal to ensure that the most relevant, helpful, and user-centered content ranks higher in search results.

The goal of HCU is to favour websites that:

  1. Prioritize content quality over SEO gimmicks.
  2. Are focused on a primary topic (as opposed to covering an excessive variety of unrelated topics).
  3. Demonstrate expertise, authority, and trustworthiness (E-A-T) in their content.

So, those who tell me to hire writers would be wrong here as I ‘am’ the one who has the expertise, authority and trustworthiness.

Favouring Niche Expertise Over Generalized Content

Google’s HCU likes to favour websites and blogs that focus on specific topics or niches, where the creator or author demonstrates clear expertise. Blogs that cover a variety of unrelated topics may struggle to rank well if Google’s algorithm views them as lacking authority on any single topic. That may be a problem since I tend to have a lot of media that I have experience in (since I am so old). This all leaves me quite uneasy about the future of my site.

Be careful and aware of AI

I see so many examples of AI use in images, and writing and even video. As scary as ai-generated content can be a useful tool as long as you do not lose the human factor. I beg that you scrutinize what you see and read, not much more I can do…

My conclusion:

I’m sorry to have written this as I totally prefer to stay on the optimistic side of being creative but I feel it had to be said. If I was starting a career of blogging now I would hesitate. Myself, I will see how long I can stay on this rollercoaster before it turns my stomach too much. I am ever grateful that you are reading this, join me in my journey, and are here on my page. I do mean that.

I’ll leave you with my to do list;

  • design a new project
  • research materials
  • make tests
  • take pictures
  • emails to check
  • text messages
  • Facebook messages
  • Facebook posts
  • Instagram DM’s
  • make instagram posts
  • edit video
  • figure out how to store video
  • write blog posts
  • edit and optimize photos
  • write a newsletter
  • list etsy items
  • pack & ship Etsy items
  • try to learn SEO
  • clean up from making
  • take a nap
  • organize all my materials
  • try to socialize
  • manage photo library
  • remember what I was doing…
  • post videos on youtube

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

188 Comments

  1. Barb
    I am subscribed to your newsletter and love your content. Thank you for articulating so clearly the challenges and concerns new technology and practices are presenting to those on the creative front. You have such talent and your projects are presented in such a way that I am inspired and confident in moving forward. Thank you for sharing yourself and know that you are greatly appreciated!
    B

  2. Thank you for the long explanation/tirade. Anyway, I tried to do a blog many many years ago. I didn’t last very long as it was so much work. At that time no $ involved coming in.
    I appreciate all of the time you spend doing your blogs. I love everything you do! Therefor when your blog pops up in my email, I save it as a priority to read.

    Keep on creating and blogging!

    Bette

    1. Yes, when I started I had signed up for a few ads through google adsense, I still remember the few pennies that started to come in. Boy was I naive! I hate to give up sooooo, I’m still here and pretty glad I am! Thanks for being part of it!

  3. Hi. I have followed your blog for around 6 years and your instructions on the use of fast setting cement has been very helpful to myself,in the ability to make some amazing draped pot plants,and keep me sane following the passing of my wife. I hope you can continue on your journey. Thank you. 👍😉😎

  4. I love that you posted this. I am absolutely, firmly, and aggressively anti-AI, and call people out for using it when I see it. It steals from artists, uses vast amounts of electricity, and turns out a garbage product, as far as I’m concerned. I love your tutorials, and if you ever decided to go the Patreon route, I’d definitely figure out a way to add you to the list of artists I already monetarily support. Please, keep doing what you’re doing and know that your efforts, creativity, and hours of work are absolutely appreciated.

    Also, on your list you should add “have a cookie” after the “take a nap” entry. You totes deserve it. 🙂

    1. I have a lot of conversations with myself during my quiet ‘making’ time and that’s when it donned on me. Cookie maybe, chocolate yes! I must say, working more has me running around more! Thankfully those bionic knees are great. Thanks for joining me!

  5. I appreciate your honesty and wish you well. I enjoy seeing all the media you use in your projects. Some I even tackled myself ! Please continue your story so we can appreciate and learn from you.

    1. Writing wasn’t always my forté but it’s what I would say if you were with me. After so many posts I’m starting to like writing! Who know’s where that will bring me! ‘Glad your with me!

  6. Hi Barb, I just want to say you are amazing and have inspired and taught me so much in my eco printing journey. I am so grateful for the generous spirit in which you have shared your knowledge with those of us who love to craft.
    When blogging first became a thing, I thought about doing it but just the thought of having to come up with things to post on a regular basis was too overwhelming. All the other parts make it a full time job and like you said in your post, things don’t stay the same so you can never relax and just cruise. I will never judge you if you decide to throw in the towel but I would certainly miss you!

    1. I appreciate the support, this has given me some ‘wind under my wings’! It’s like a large parrot sitting on my shoulder constantly pecking at my head; ‘ you’ve got to get to the blog stuff!’

  7. Dear Barb, I haven’t written before but I have been in awe of your talent for a long time. Thank you for the clear explanation of the new reality facing creators and bloggers.
    I am mostly a vegetable farmer, but way old…71… and I have all these plans to do craft stuff before I die, and I will carry on with this plan, but I so hear you on how the digital world has taken away autonomy from everything we create, except the stuff you can pull out of the soil….. haha! Thank goodness for composting. perhaps a digital composter would get rid of all the annuals , biennials and short lived perennials…
    Love you , Sue

    1. That’s a good way of thinking of it. I love to hear how diverse my followers are and I’m pretty sure I could get along with you. All the power to your plans! You are very grounded.

  8. Hi Barb. Thank you for this well-timed and well-considered post. I think your points are excellent, echoing what MANY of us (especially the less young of us!) feel. Things have changed so fast and so significantly in the last few years that even those in their 30’s are struggling to keep up while those of us well passed our 30’s are saddled with the mixed blessings of wisdom, experience and hindsight. Can I just say that I think you are one of THE most creative people I’ve come across – I just LOVE the variety, the fun, the colours, textures and beauty of your imaginative creations – and I very much hope you will continue to share your journey with us. I do wish I had more time to visit your site (I think you were the very first person I ever “followed”, or kept tags on, having had no interest or intentions to “follow” anyone before: that’s how inspirational you are!). Thank you so much for your generous content, for sharing your time and great talent, and for remaining a genuinely colourful artist within an increasingly grey field. Surely, the world’s creativity pendulum will swing back after it has completely lost its lustre in the soulless grey of AI – and hopefully that will happen within our lifetime. You certainly deserve to be recognised and I wish you all the best and much success going forward. (BTW, have you ever considered maybe holding artist retreats and sharing on-hand skills, perhaps paring with some health treatments, etc? There are an increasing number of people searching for the human, the soulful, amongst the cold garble of our tech world. Retreats or day workshops may make more money and might even be less work than trying to fight the big G?! Just a thought :-))

    1. I agree with you! I was cautious to write this since I always try to imagine it as a reader wondering if I would want to hear that. I’m so amazed at how faithful some of my readers are. I wouldn’t know where to find that in those analytic graphs. I’m getting the sense too that they are genuine creative souls who are not just here for a quick ‘fix’. ‘How comforting! I do get asked all the time about workshops. I have very vivid memories of my college teaching days where I was almost like a packhorse slugging stuff around. Yes, younger students tend to be ‘needier’ but it was utterly exhausting. Some of the high costs I see for these retreats also makes me question. Insurance & accessibility makes home classes impossible. I’m definitely seeing a trend of paid online courses. I taught for the college during covid so I know what is involved. Maybe someday! I just have to keep remembering that I am getting older! Thanks for your thoughts!

  9. Thanks for providing an honest report. I am a retired art educator re-
    entering the artist path I am working through the steps; gallery and art organization membership s, entering my art in gallery exhibits, Juried shows, and my first solo show is in May. As I am creating cohesive art for the show, I am almost ready to create and post on a website. Your article is very helpful as I move forward. Follow me on FB: riseaboveartist. My IG@riseaboveartist is slow as my only messages are from scammers

    1. You make some wonderful heartfelt pieces. As you may have read I am actually an illustrator who wanted some change from sitting at a drafting table. I can appreciate what it takes to go that route like you. I have considered it since it seems a bit more simple for managing supplies but also such a hugely competitive world, especially now as the whole world is at your fingertips! You should see how many supplies I need. I admire your ambitions, you go girl!